To the Male/Female Scholar-Athletes of the Year
| 2020 | Emily Berzolla, Soccer Yorai Shaoul, Track and Field |
| 2019 | Abby Bertics, Volleyball Tim Roberts, Basketball |
| 2018 | Katie Shade, Softball Aidan Gilson, Cross Country/Track and Field |
| 2017 | Maryann Gong, Cross Country/Track and Field Daniel Smith, Swimming and Diving Harris Stolzenberg, Lacrosse |
| 2016 | Margaret Guo, Swimming and Diving Arinze Okeke, Track and Field |
| 2015 | Maryann Gong, Cross Country/Track and Field Daryl Neubieser, Swimming and Diving |
| 2014 | Louise van den Heuvel, Cross Country/Track and Field Tyler Singer-Clark, Track and Field |
| 2013 | Lauren Kuntz, Track and Field Katie Spielbauer, Volleyball Joseph Rafidi, Fencing |
| 2012 | Lauren Kuntz, Track and Field Molly McShane, Field Hockey and Lacrosse Noel Hollingsworth, Basketball |
| 2011 | Lauren Hernley, Soccer and Swimming and Diving Kyle Hannon, Track and Field |
| 2010 | Alex May, Volleyball Jeff Zhou, Swimming and Diving |
| 2009 | Alex May, Volleyball James Oleinik, Football |
| 2008 | Julia Zimmerman, Gymnastics Jimmy Bartolotta, Basketball |
| 2007 | Julia Zimmerman, Gymnastics Ryan Sheffler, Soccer |
| 2006 | Karen Kinnaman, Basketball Uzoma Orji, Track and Field |
| 2005 | Regina Sullivan, Ice Hockey David Schannon, Pistol |
| 2004 | Martha Buckley, Cross Country and Track and Field Rory Foster, Soccer |
| 2003 | Audrey Wang, Pistol Sean Nolan, Cross Country and Track and Field |
| 2002 | Michele Verticchio, Field Hockey and Ice Hockey Daniel R. Feldman, Cross Country and Indoor Track and Field |
| 2001 | Cristina Estrada, Basketball Derek G. Southwell, Nordic Skiing |
| 2000 | Mealani K. Nakamura, Tennis John C. Olsson, Gymnastics |
| 1999 | Victoria A. Best, Basketball Jason C. Miller, Gymnastics |
| 1998 | R. Bradley Gray, Football Nicole D. Gerrish, Basketball |
| 1997 | N. Katherine Merrilees, Field Hockey and Lacrosse Ben W. Leong, Pistol |
| 1996 | Jennifer M. Boyle, Basketball and Track and Field Tobias H. Ayer, Heavyweight Crew |
| 1995 | Agnieszka Reiss Jesse C. Darley, Cross Country and Track and Field |
| 1994 | Valerie P. Tan Jay A. Muelhoefer |
| 1993 | Seema Jayachandran Roderick D. Tranum, Football |
| 1992 | Lisa K. Arel, Amy J. Rovelstad Rodrigo R. Rubiano, Football |
| 1991 | Fiona P.S. Tan Darcy D. Prather, Football |
| 1990 | Maureen T. Fahey Anthony G. Lapes |
| 1989 | Christina Alvord Eric M. Reifschneider |
| 1988 | Diane E. DiMassa Roderick T. Hinman |
| 1987 | Jeri Ann S. Ikeda Michael F. Foley |
| 1986 | Julie Chen Jerry L. Martin |
| 1985 | Patrice M. Parris, Track and Field Lisa A. Shields, Tennis |
| 1984 | Louise Jandura, Basketball, Field Hockey, Softball Kenneth R. Shull, Wrestling |
| 1983 | Margaret L. Kniffin, Volleyball John S. Schmitz, Swimming |
| 1982 | Karen M. Klincewicz, Swimming Mark S. LaRow, Swimming |
| 1981 | Edward N. Marcus, Sailing Nancy H. Robinson, Fencing |
| 1980 | Raymond J. Nagem, Basketball |
| 1979 | Leonard E. Dolhert, Sailing |
| 1978 | Neal L. Rockowitz, Squash, Tennis |
| 1977 | Frank C. Richardson, Cross Country, Track |
| 1976 | Jon W. Johnson, Gymnastics |
| Award known as the ECAC Merit Medal | |
| 1975 | Charles L. Tucker III, Sailing |
| 1974 | Lawrence D. Bell, Gymnastics |
| 1973 | Alan G. Spoon, Sailing |
| 1972 | Paul E. Mitchell, Wrestling |
| 1971 | Lawrence C. Markel, Swimming, Water Polo |
| 1970 | David M. Rapoport, Fencing |
| 1969 | Geoffrey G. Hallock, Cross Country |
| 1968 | David G. Jansson, Basketball |
| 1967 | Michael A. Crane, Swimming |
| 1966 | Terry L. Cronburg, Sailing |
| 1965 | James L. Larsen, Basketball, Lacrosse |
| 1964 | Martin T. Poe III, Heavyweight Crew |
| 1963 | Thomas P. Gerritty, Jr., Wrestling |
| 1962 | Phillip J. Robinson, Lacrosse |
Other Awards
Johnson Schumacker Cochrane