| 2019 |
Devon Goetz, Field Hockey and Softball |
| 2018 |
Emily Penn, Field Hockey |
| 2017 |
Veronika Jedryka, Swimming and Diving |
| 2016 |
Cimran Virdi, Track and Field |
| 2015 |
Cimran Virdi, Track and Field |
| 2014 |
Cimran Virdi, Track and Field |
| 2013 |
Molly McShane, Field Hockey and Lacrosse |
| 2012 |
Kameron Klauber, Field Hockey |
| 2011 |
Karin Fisher, Track and Field |
| 2010 |
Anna Kokensparger, Swimming and Diving |
| 2009 |
Julia Zimmerman, Gymnastics |
| 2008 |
Doria Holbrook, Swimming and Diving |
| 2007 |
Doria Holbrook, Swimming and Diving |
| 2006 |
Deanna Lentz, Field Hockey and Lacrosse |
| 2005 |
Doria Holbrook, Swimming and Diving |
| 2004 |
Kathryn Duffy, Swimming and Diving |
| 2003 |
Kelly Martens, Volleyball |
| 2002 |
Princess Imoukhuede, Track and Field |
| 2001 |
Sonja J. Ellefson, Gymnastics |
| 2000 |
Caroline M. Purcell, Fencing |
| 1999 |
Deirdre K. Dunn, Swimming and Diving |
| 1998 |
Tracey C. Ho, Pistol |
| 1997 |
Myong-Sin Yi, Pistol |
| 1996 |
N. Katherine Merrilees, Field Hockey and Lacrosse |
| 1995 |
Sheila C. Rocchio, Gymnastics |
| 1994 |
Kamilah Alexander, Volleyball |
| 1993 |
Julie K. Lyren, Gymnastics |
| 1992 |
Lisa K. Arel, Gymnastics |
| 1991 |
Lisa K. Arel, Gymnastics |
| 1990 |
Yvonne M. Grierson, Swimming and Diving |
| 1989 |
Yvonne M. Grierson, Swimming and Diving |
| 1988 |
Yvonne M. Grierson, Swimming and Diving |
| 1987 |
Martha A. Beverage, Basketball |
| 1986 |
Grace M. Saccardo, Soccer, Softball and Basketball |
| 1985 |
Lori A. Blackwelder Peterson, Swimming and Diving |
| 1984 |
Cynthia C. Robinson, Basketball and Softball |
| 1983 |
Anella E. Munro, Volleyball |
| 1982 |
Karen M. Klincewicz, Swimming and Diving |
| 1981 |
Julia R. Neuringer, Field Hockey |
| 1980 |
Karen M. Klincewicz, Swimming and Diving |
| 1979 |
Diane L. Medved, Crew |
| 1978 |
Sheila L. Luster, Basketball and Volleyball |
| 1977 |
Barbara A. Belt, Sailing |
| 1976 |
Ingrid L. Klass, Crew |
| 1975 |
Deborah Stein, Skiing |