To the Outstanding Male/Female Freshmen Athletes of the Year
| 2019 | Eva Then, Lacrosse Laura Rosado, Swimming and Diving Jay Lang, Swimming and Diving |
| 2018 | Andie Maloney, Volleyball Hamilton Forsythe, Basketball |
| 2017 | Devon Goetz, Field Hockey and Softball Bouke Edskes, Swimming and Diving |
| 2016 | Kara Holinski, Basketball Bailey Tregoning, Field Hockey, Track and Field Adis Ojeda, Football |
| 2015 | Amanda Wu, Swimming and Diving Austin Filiere, Baseball |
| 2014 | Veronika Jedryka, Swimming and Diving Harris Stolzenberg, Lacrosse |
| 2013 | Sarah Quinn, Cross Country and Track and Field Kale Rogers, Water Polo and Swimming and Diving |
| 2012 | Emmie Ryan, Swimming and Diving Justin Wallace, Football |
| 2011 | Lauren Quisenberry, Tennis Colby Dunn, Swimming and Diving |
| 2010 | Anna Kokensparger, Swimming and Diving Matt Hohenberger, Volleyball |
| 2009 | Portia Jones, Track and Field Tim Stumbaugh, Swimming and Diving |
| 2008 | Amy Jacobi, Swimming and Diving Michael Dobson, Swimming and Diving |
| 2007 | Alex May, Volleyball Rastislav Racz, Swimming and Diving |
| 2006 | Julia Zimmerman, Gymnastics Rick Mancuso, Football |
| 2005 | Doria Holbrook, Swimming and Diving Praveen Pamidimukkala, Volleyball |
| 2004 | Kate Thornton, Swimming and Diving Craig Edwards, Swimming and Diving |
| 2003 | Austin Zimmerman, Volleyball Evan Tindell, Tennis |
| 2002 | Merritt S. Tam, Gymnastics Nicholas O. Sidelnik, Swimming and Diving |
| 2001 | Nydia M. Clayton, Volleyball, Track and Field Douglas L. Allaire, Soccer and Baseball |
| 2000 | Kirstin M. Alberi, Swimming and Diving Craig D. Mielcarz, Track and Field |
| 1999 | Jessica Hall, Tennis Thomas J. Hynes, Football and Men's Lacrosse |
| 1998 | Christopher S. McGuire, Cross Country and Track Sonja J. Ellefson, Gymnastics |
| 1997 | Mealani Nakamura, Tennis John A. Schaeffer, Soccer, Basketball and Lacrosse |
| 1996 | Eve Phillips, Cross Country Jason C. Miller, Gymnastics |
| 1995 | Janis H. Eisenberg, Cross Country and Track and Field Michael T. Butville, Lacrosse |
| 1994 | |
| 1993 | |
| 1992 | |
| 1991 | |
| 1990 | |
| 1989 | |
| 1988 | Alyssa B. Parker, Soccer and Ice Hockey Joshua N. Ertischek, Wrestling and Football |
| 1987 | Yvonne M. Grierson, Swimming and Diving Robert C. Kupbens, Football |
| 1986 | Catherine M. Rocchio, Gymnastics David Chang, Soccer |
| 1985 | Benjarmin C. Spehlmann, Tennis Linda M. Sprys, Swimming and Diving |
| 1984 | Martha A. Beverage, Basketball and Field Hockey Clark E. Dorman, Swimming and Diving Gordon C. Holterman, Cross Country and Track |
| 1983 | Lori A. Blackwelder, Swimming and Diving Craig N. Poole, Baseball and Basketball |
| 1982 | Clifford J. Eskey, Rifle Andrew A. Renshaw, Lacrosse and Swimming |
| 1981 | Robert W. Schoenlein, Swimming and Water Polo Kenneth R. Shull, Wrestling |
| 1980 | Paul S. Neves, Cross Country/Track and Field John S. Schmitz, Water Polo and Swimming |
| 1979 | Karen M. Klincewicz, Swimming and Diving |
| 1978 | Leslie A. Harris, Gymnastics |
| 1977 | John M. Dieken, Swimming and Diving |
| 1976 | Barry L. Bayus, Cross Country and Track Elaine D. Sears, Gymnastics |
| 1975 | Mark J.T. Smith, Fencing |
| 1974 | Johan G. Akerman, Fencing |
| 1973 | Shinichiro Yoshida |
| 1972 | David A. Deacon |
| 1971 | Kenneth A. Epstein |
| 1970 | Stephen L. Cochi David R. Wilson, Track and Field |
| 1969 | Albert K. Lau, Track and Field Peter A. Sanders, Water Polo and Swimming |
| 1968 | Z. Gerry Maskiewicz, Soccer Bruce J. Davies |
| 1967 | Ben T. Wilson, Track and Field/Basketball Frederic W. Andree, Track and Field/Wrestling |
| 1966 | Luis A. Clare Stanley M. Kozubek, Track and Field |
| 1965 | John C. McFarren Norman E. Hawkins |
| 1964 | Alexander D. Wilson, Basketball David Schramm, Wrestling |
Other Awards
Johnson Schumacker Kispert